An elegy of unbelonging

“In a recent X post, I promised to share my thoughts on Sonia Gandhi's new memoir, Belonging, which has sparked intense debate across India and beyond. First, a few caveats on what this piece is not. I…”
In a recent X post, I promised to share my thoughts on Sonia Gandhi's new memoir, Belonging, which has sparked intense debate across India and beyond.
First, a few caveats on what this piece is not. It is neither a book review nor a critical audit. The analytical tools that usually serve me well in matters of politics and reason feel inadequate against such an unrelenting tide of raw emotion.
Yet neither is this a hagiography. At the heart of the book lies an emotive core that shifts hue from sheer love to grief, bewilderment, and quiet acceptance. What follows, then, is a map of the emotions the book stirred in me.
"Stay connected with Aman-e-Pakistan for ongoing live reporting and verified investigative updates."
For your own emotional safety, I do not recommend reading this book. But if you must, read it for its emotional range and velocity, not for the subjectivity of the author's historical commentary. Now to the book.
The cover image first. Framed in vintage monochrome, a young Mrs Gandhi meets the camera with a steady, guarded gaze, dark waves falling past her shoulders. Her fingers curl softly beneath her chin, an index finger resting just below her lower lip, as if the young woman looking back has only just stopped chewing her nails in nervousness.
Had this book pretended to be anything more than an honest emotional chronicle of a life in the public eye, we would have seen present-day Mrs Gandhi sitting behind a wooden desk, signing important-looking documents under a title like 'My Struggle' or 'My Destiny'. The title itself is the second giveaway.
On the surface, belonging is a gerund, a verb serving as a noun. Yet it is the verb that caught me off guard here. We South Asians are accustomed to its passive use, as in 'I belong to my country', rather than its active exertion, 'I am trying to belong.
' It is as if you say to me, 'Farrukh, try, try harder,' and I reply, 'I am trying, I am trying. ' By virtue of being an active verb, the effort remains incomplete, ongoing, and quietly defiant: 'I will continue to try to belong.
What are you going to do about it? 'The story opens with a meet-cute at a Cambridge Greek restaurant, launching her courtship with Rajiv Gandhi. Scattered through these early pages are casual remarks about food across countries that made me smile.
Why a Greek restaurant? Because its Mediterranean flavours were the closest thing to the delicious food back home. As for the British, she writes: 'Average British food in those days was a punishment for an Italian
Here everything was tasteless and mostly colourless, boiled with no herbs, no seasoning, apart from salt and occasionally pepper. I'd dispose of their breakfast of eggs, bacon, and baked beans by opening the window of my tiny room and flinging it out into a grassy clearing below.
' Later, she would struggle to adjust to Indian food as well. I jump ahead only to round off the culinary thread, and to note how unsparing yet enjoyable those remarks are.
What follows is the stuff of fairytales: a Prince Charming from a distant, exotic kingdom, romance across Europe, and a first act of defiance in choosing her prince over her roots. Rajiv Gandhi comes out looking rather well here.
That is to be expected, of course, since he was the centre of her life. Even so, the charm lies in the small details: his unassuming manner, thoughtfulness, frugal lifestyle, and readiness to do hard labour all do him credit.
After this prolonged courtship, one expects a wedding and a happily ever after. Yet herein lies the greatest bait and switch of history. She travels to her prince's unfamiliar homeland and marries him.
Initially, she has great luck adapting to her new life. Indira Gandhi, the iron lady to the country, is a soft, caring mother-in-law to her. Before her wedding, she stays with the renowned Bachchan family, the Bollywood actor being Rajiv's personal friend.
Her brother-in-law and the household staff are all warmly supportive. But what is the point of a tragedy if it does not first offer a false sense of security? One by one, her safety nets are ripped away.
Politics soon makes it apparent that she has walked into a deeply polarised and insecure land. I did not find her making excuses for family miscalculations like the Emergency's forced sterilisation campaign. When the backlash arrives, she shares the unvarnished dread for her brother-in-law's life, followed by a frugal existence in exile from power.
Then, in merciless succession, they are all taken from her. Her brother-in-law dies in a tragic crash. Next come the graphic details of her mother-in-law's murder, and finally the loss of her husband, killed by a suicide bomber, which leaves her consumed with worry for her children's well-being.
Anyone following the book's coverage in the Indian media will notice how mindlessly obtuse most of it has been. Commentators complain she has not addressed every controversy of Congress rule, yet fail to notice she has not been overly critical even of her worst detractors.
Perhaps most are unacquainted with the purpose of an autobiography. Its point is never a cold historical audit, but sharing the author's lived experience. And when someone who has suffered this degree of loss shares her tale, you do not sit in judgement; you lower your gaze, listen with rapt attention, and nod politely.
I do not want to leave you with the impression that this is a tear-jerker. It is not. Between so many tragedies, there is a great deal of life, innocent fun, warmth, affection, exploration and resilience.
Still, you invariably end up feeling sorry. Not for her, but for the land that could not truly appreciate such unconditional love. After Rajiv's death, despite being intensely private, she was thrust into active political life.
The political class accepted her only while power remained out of reach. The moment assuming office became a real prospect, she was disowned in a heartbeat over her foreign origins.
The betrayal is most pronounced with trusted allies like Sharad Pawar, the very man who years later would pressure Dr Manmohan Singh not to block the then Gujarat chief minister Narendra Modi's visit to Israel. Consequently, today's India has traded a doctorate in economics like Dr Singh for Modi with his master's in 'entire political science'.
The wages of insecurity could not be more self-evident. Something must be said about this perpetual South Asian insecurity that makes belonging so hard. I comment on every part of the world and usually my attention is welcomed.
Only in South Asia am I asked who I am and why I am writing about us. After three decades dedicated to this profession and this region, I still do not feel I belong anywhere.
And I am native-born. Anyone arriving here without power or wealth, armed only with love, should be : belonging here is never granted, only attempted.
Continue Reading: More in International
Swipe or click arrows to explore International desk coverage





